Reaping
Note: The pictures
and descriptions in this post are graphic representations of death and
dismemberment. I discuss sheep being sent to the factory to be killed; I
discuss a lamb being hit by an ATV and then skinned and gutted; I discuss many
sheep dying of natural causes. There are pictures. I am not a vegetarian in any
sense. Please do not read if this will offend you.
So now
that the snow has turned to rain (at least on the east coast, at least in
Baltimore) and everyone is slogging through the sugar crashes that come after
the Christmas feasts, it is my chance to turn from funny and vibrant to grim
and gruesome.
A post or two ago I casually mentioned that if
a sheep has a bum leg and it doesn’t get better then the farmer assumes it has
a parasite has to kill and bury it. This might also happen if a ewe has a hard
udder, or any other number of maladies. If the sheep isn’t getting better,
through a number of penicillin injections, then the farmer needs to kill it.
I also
mentioned, quite casually, that if the sheep runs herself (or, in the case of a
lamb, maybe himself) aground, if the sheep breaks a leg or bashes their head
in, the farmer has no problem skinning and eating it. This is true. This is
only true, though, if the farmer has time to skin it. It also isn’t a bonus for
the farmer by any means. The farmer already has a freezer full of meat; they
don’t need any more.
Ron and
Gay take care of a herd of Merino sheep on a portion of their land that they
don’t keep for pasture—it’s wild land and the sheep there are wild, too. Every
so often they bring the Merinos in for shearing, so they don’t get too tangled
up in Manuka (a type of tree). At that point they’ll kill eight or twelve of
them and freeze the meat for “house meat.” They don’t sell the Merinos because
unlike domesticated sheep, Merinos don’t walk through an open gate, they leap
over where the gate would have been if it was still closed. Unlike a
domesticated sheep, they don’t gently run past you; they knock holes in the
walls in their effort to escape. Sending them to a factory, making them run in
lines, herding them through the runs, would be unkind, and so Ron and Gay don’t
do it; they let their herd of Merinos stay as wild as possible. Their house meat
comes from those Merinos.
So
every lamb or sheep that does itself an injury is a negative in their account
balance. If a sheep leaps over a fence
in the covered yard, while we’re dagging, say, and snaps her leg—that’s an
awful thing to witness, first of all. The sheep is terrified. The other sheep
can smell the blood, the first sheep is thrashing around, blood everywhere, and
what choice does the farmer have? He has to slit her throat. She won’t recover
from a broken leg. If he has time to skin her he will, but if she’s a full
grown ewe then her meat’s too tough for much else but dog meat.
Second
of all, when that happens, Gay usually says, “Ah, well that’s seventy dollars
down.”
Because
it is. They could have sold that ewe to the works for seventy dollars, and now
she’s being used for dog meat.
It’s worse when it’s a lamb, because a lamb
could be sold for ninety dollars, hopefully a hundred if the lamb is heavy
enough.
One morning
we are herding a mob of ewes and lambs across the road and a couple sheep
billow out to the side of the road to the gully of drift wood, weeds and
fencing that runs along the road and the paddock. We run behind the sheep and get
them to run back through the gate, and then close the gate behind them, so that
they won’t all stream out again, but there is one lamb that jumps through the
fence in the wrong direction, out of the paddock (this is not unusual, as lambs
are small enough to fit through the wires of the fence, or under the wires of
the fence), or had not gone with the rest of the mob in the first place—in any
case, we find him in the gully when the gate is shut. He’s frantic, and the
bike is on, making a rumbling noise that scares him even more, and the gate is
shut. He runs towards the gate, the very hard mesh metal gate, and bashes right
into it.
I’ve
seen many sheep run right into mesh metal gates before. They do it on a routine
basis. But this one hits his head in just the wrong way, just the wrong angle.
It retreats back a few steps and I think, “Oh, it’s ok,” but Gay says, “Oh,
poor wee thing, I’ve seen them do this, probably won’t make it, just hit on the
brain pan wrong.” The lamb looks unsteady on its feet, like in those cartoons
it would have stars circling around it’s head, or little Tweety birds.
I think,
“You don’t know, he looks ok, maybe he
will make it.” I don’t say anything, and we don’t have time to stop and
check and worry. We have another mob of sheep to shift. We get on the bikes and
leave it.
When we
get back it’s lying by the gate, dead, and Gay says, “Ah, well, that’s seventy
dollars down,” and I think, “More like ninety, or ninty four,” because he may
only be worth seventy now, but by the time they would have sent him to the
works he would have been heavy enough to be worth ninety, at least, if not
more.
A few
days later we go back to the gate and the lamb is still lying there because we’ve
had a busy couple days and haven’t had a chance to collect it. Ron and Gay pick
it up by its hooves and put it in a small metal trailer that hooked onto the
bike. It smells sweet and foul, like trash, like a landfill. Of course there are
flies. The lamb’s stomach has exploded out of its belly from the gas, so the
wool has cut away and you can see a green bubble thing protruding outwards.
Ron drives
the bike across the main road to the trail he uses to get across his land,
through the various paddocks. He sets the trailer just there, by the side of
the trail. He’ll come back later and bury it. For now he just has to get it out
of the road.
Two
days later the smell and the flies are still there, by the gate, by the side of
the road, where the lamb had been.
And
through all of this I feel nothing.
I’ve
never been particularly squeamish about death, or about blood, or guts. My own
cats are a completely different story, and I am choking up just thinking about
the support group they advertised in my local grocery store for pet owners who’ve
lost a furry loved one, but in general I have not had much experience with
death. At the nurses office I look away from the needle, but only because I
don’t want to psych myself out about the pain, and because it’s a ritual to do
so, not because I’m particularly upset about the fact that my blood won’t be in
my body anymore. In biology class I named my frog along with everyone else.
Those of you who have lived with me or who are close family members can attest
to the fact that I like eating and cooking bizarre parts of the body, like
tongue or heart (cheaper AND delicious!). I’m not partial to liver, but that’s
because it is genuinely disgusting, and that’s a scientifically proven fact.
The
sheep on Ron and Gay’s farm live a very happy life, all told. They romp and
play among the manuka, in the pines, over the hills. They settle in the
pasture. Ron and Gay handle them as gently as possible, and when they use their
dog, Kelly, as a herding device she doesn’t draw blood, even though sometimes
they do get so stressed out by, say, being forced into a small pen where
machines are going and a dog is barking that one of them may have a heart
attack right there at your feet (I’m talking about Shearing day, which will be
a whole post in and of itself, don’t worry). Sometimes they tip over onto their
backs and can’t get up; days later we’ll find them just wool scattered around;
brown, gooey meat, offal and a pair of ribs sticking up out of the ground are
all that’s left from what the scavenger birds have picked off. Sometimes a lamb
will milk its mother until she’s skin and bones; sometimes those ewes can be
fed up once the lambs are weaned, but sometimes they’re too far gone and have
to just be mercifully killed. Generally,
though, they have a great life, a fairly healthy, happy life, especially when
you compare it to some of these animals that live in pens just big enough for
them to breathe, and sometimes, not even then.
So I
have no problem when eventually most of them have to go to “the Works.” I know
that other people would have a problem with that. But that is the trade off.
When you are a farm animal, your needs are taken care of. You are protected
from predators; you are fed; you are sheared; you are kept healthy; your
children are kept healthy; you have no worries and do not have to fend for
yourself. But the trade off is that your body is not your own. Your wool, eggs,
feathers—your very body is forfeit. Humans, having such strong personal
identities, would say that that trade off is unfair. Would a sheep say that?
Would a peacock say that? Can you answer that question fairly? A human’s
perspective is so thoroughly based in this concept of “I” and “Me,” that we
cannot trade ourselves for anything, but a sheep’s perspective may be much more
based in the collective mob, or it may be based on the grass, or on the sun, or
on their lambs. It may be based on smells or sounds. If they were able to
answer, they may be willing to trade their body for protection and food. They may consider one to be less important
than the other in the short term.
That is
conjecture, though. I do not know what a sheep would want. I assume they do not
want to die, but as for the rest of it, I can never know. We can never know. We
can only guess, and do the best we can with what we see, how we interpret their
reactions to experiences. I see them huddling together, each sheep pressing
their sides so close together that you can barely wade through them, following
one another as close to the previous one’s rump as possible. I interpret that
as them needing to be together, in a mob. I interpret that as feeling like they
would rather be in a mob than alone, and that if they are going to walk to
their deaths, they’d rather do it in a crowd than by themselves. What else can
I interpret it as?
Fear, I
can interpret it as fear.
The
morning of the reaping I wake up late. Ron and Gay told me the truck was coming
to take the ewes and lambs away at 7:30, and we had to wean the lambs before
then, but I don’t have a clock in my room and if they had knocked on my door I hadn’t
heard it. The house is empty, no
breakfast on the table (an unheard of thing), and I can’t see anyone in the
yards.
But there’s
an unholy racket of sheep maaing coming from the covered yards.
So I
throw on my overalls and my gum boots and book it over to the shed, where
paddocks full of already separated sheep and lambs stare back at me. Ron and
Gay had shifted probably two mobs of sheep early this morning, weaned them, and
now had them all in their right paddocks. Only two paddocks worth will go to the Works; the lambs and certain ewes.
The other ewes are “replacement” ewes, which just means that they’ll live to
breed again. We let the replacement ewes go and they scatter through the yard.
Me and Gay and the replacement ewes |
Everyone
is crying and maaing and upset. Ron and Gay are talking about logistics and
simultaneously cleaning out the run that will take the sheep from the covered
yard to the truck. It’s a small run that leads to a metal loading ramp with
weights at the end, so that Ron can lift the ramp at the close end, the weights
at the far end will go down, and the far end of the ramp will go higher so that
the sheep will be able to climb to a higher level of the truck.
Then we
are waiting for the truck in the early morning light. Simon is taking pictures.
He has a giant, million dollar camera that can do everything but zoom in really
far, so getting wildlife photos with his camera is impossible. He experiments
with the sheep. They finish getting the run cleared out. The truck is a little
bit late.
But the
truck comes, we open the gate for it, and it backs in as if it’s done this a
million times before. Out pops a man in Richard Simmons’ gear (tank top and
short shorts in faded neon colors), with giant ears and a shaved head. The
second man, his driving mate, is in less ridiculous clothing. The first guy is
leaping over fences and each time I’m slightly terrified that I will see
something I’m not sure I want to see.
But
both of them know how to handle sheep. Immediately Ron, Gay and the two men get
the first lot of ewes into the run and up the loading ramp. The ewes respond to
the run like they respond to every run—the weaning run, the dagging run. Some
of them get turned around, some of them balk, but generally when they see their
fellows turning a corner or going up ahead in front of them, they follow along
behind. They want to stick together.
I feel a little useless because I know I
couldn’t be as effective as these two truck drivers are at getting the sheep
into the truck. They are sheep herding professionals. Ron and Gay don’t ask for
Simon and I’s help—they need to get this done quickly. They don’t have time to
baby us through anything.
Soon
it’s the lambs’ turn. The lambs go up the ramp just as well as the ewes did.
Every once in a while one of the men from the truck will shut a gate in the
truck, and open another one. Or Ron will hike the ramp up a little higher, so
that the sheep can get to the next level of the truck.
In half
an hour it’s done. Ron’s made his own count, the guys on the truck have made
theirs, and the numbers match up. Ron and Gay will send about 70 ewes and 73
lambs to the works today. They won’t get paid for these sheep for another ten
days. As Gay says, “Most farmers work on an overdraft most of the year, so it’s
nice to see that overdraft go down.” They’ll do this several more times in the
course of the season until their lambs are all sold. They need to keep enough
ewes and enough lambs to repopulate for next year, but they also need to
remember that winter is difficult and a lot of the sheep won’t survive through
it, so it’s better to sell them now. They
need to sell enough lambs to cover the cost of the farm—the cost of the
machines, the cost of repairing the machines, the cost of gas (10 dollars a
gallon, without government subsidies and with extra taxes) for the bikes and
the tractor and the mower, the cost of running a house, the cost of day to day
living, the cost of taking care of these animals. They need to sell enough
lambs to make it all worthwhile. So if you’ve picked through this post and done
the numbers and figured out how much they made from this truck load of lambs
and ewes and you thought, “wow, that’s a large number,” remember that their
costs are high as well, and that this predicated on the assumption that Ron and
Gay are healthy and able to work 365 days a year, with volunteers who just ask
for food and shelter. What if Ron gets
sick? What happens then?
Gay and
Ron have been doing this for thirty years. They know how to run a farm. Their
fences are in good order, they’ve got their timing right, they’ve got all their
tracks set up to the best effect so that herding goes as smoothly as possible.
When they were starting, when they grew up on farms, they would pick the wool
off the fences to sell that, so they wouldn’t waste any. They would sell the
dag off the back ends of the sheep for use as fertilizer in town. They don’t
have to do that now because they’ve gotten to a fairly even keeled position. There
are a lot of ways they don’t have to cut corners, now.
But
still. I can’t help but think that it’s a precarious position to be in. As Gay
says, “Ah, well, that’s seventy dollars down.”
When
the yard is empty and silent again, when the truck is gone, we go up to the
house and have breakfast.
Later
that day we wean more lambs, which means shifting them. We have them in several
paddocks. Weaned lambs are notoriously difficult to shift because they don’t
flow in a mob the way regular sheep do. They break off in clumps and spook at
everything. They’re used to following their mothers, but now they have no
mothers to follow, so it’s sort of a blind leading the blind, and things can go
terribly wrong.
So what
happens is Ron pushes them, with the bike, to go through one gate, across the
road, and hopefully through another gate. But instead what happens is that they
get onto the road, look around, and decide that instead of going through the
gate on the other side they’re going to run right up the road. Simon is
standing on the road in order to try and stop them from going that way. If he
stands with his arms out and makes a noise it might scare them into stopping
and turning around. But he’s standing too close and the lambs have got up a
good speed by the time he realizes they’re coming for him. They rush right past
him and don’t see his spread arms. He has no chance to stop them, and they run
up the road.
Some of
them run through the gate we wanted, some of them run back into the paddock
they came from, and the rest gleefully bound away down the main road that
connects to another main road, where cars whizz by at a million miles an hour.
So Ron
and Gay rush away to try and herd them back up. They are experienced herders,
and manage it, but that was only half the mob of weaned lambs, so when we get
them through the gate we want them in (finally, after like, forty five
minutes), Ron goes back to another paddock for more. I’m standing at the gate
by the road, waiting to herd more in, when Ron on his bike zoom up to me. Simon
and Gay are off ushering the last lot up the trail into the paddock where
they’ll stay for the duration.
Ron
hops off the bike, closes the gate, and I’m confused but I see something on the
back of his bike, the part I sit. It’s a rough piece of grippey material so you
can hold things just because of the texture. You don’t have to strap things
down.
On the
back of his bike is something white. Ron is talking and making appropriate hand
gestures.
“I was
just coming out from the trees and I saw one, two, and I thought, oh I bet
there’s a third one and there was a third one, but it leapt almost clear across
the windshield, but in fact it hit right there,” here he gestures to where the
lamb hit the bike, his elbows sticking out, “Did about five hundred dollars of
damage to the radiator. Just there. But it ran out and I thought, oh, did I get
it, but then I didn’t see it moving so I doubled back, and yes, I did get it.”
Over
the course of the afternoon and evening Ron will repeat this story three or
four times. In fact, every time I bring up the lamb he will repeat this story.
He won’t repeat it word for word—sometimes he’ll add description, sometimes
he’ll take away description, but he will repeat himself in a pattern, in a
predictable way.
“So,
hop on.”
“What?”
“hop
on. I’ll take you back. I’m going to skin and gut this. The bruising means we
won’t be able to use the left side, where I hit it, but we’ll be able to use
the right side all right.”
I look
at the bike. The white thing on the back of the bike is the dead lamb. I hear in the back of my head Gay’s voice
saying, “Ah, well, that’s seventy dollars down.”
“Is
there room?” I ask.
“Ah,
yea, just maybe budge it up, probably room,” Ron says.
I swing
my leg around so that I’m behind Ron. The lamb is splayed out across the back
of the bike, blood flecked across it’s muzzle, it’s eyes open. There’s not too
much blood, but what is there is spread over the wool, in thin lines and webs,
caught from one clot to the next. What is more bizarre to me is that as the
bike picks up speed the lamb’s body jiggles with the movement. I’m worried
about one or both of us slipping off, so I clench my fingers into a non-bloody
portion of wool, to hold onto the body, in case we go around any sudden
corners.
But
there are no mishaps, and Ron takes us to the shearing shed. I pause for a
moment, wondering if I should follow, not sure, but then I think, yes, I should
follow, he has not told me to stay, and so I follow where I saw him disappear
to, and after that I follow the small droplets of blood that I find on the
floor, and I eventually find Ron and the dead lamb in the shearing shed.
The
Shearing shed is where the shearing generally takes place. You will hear all
about the shearing shed when I tell you about the shearing. Today there are
maybe twelve sheep waiting to dry out for Ron to shear them in the morning, so
they watch the proceedings.
I ask
Ron if I can watch, too. He’s sharpening his knife and he looks at me for just
a moment before agreeing, readily. He has shown other volunteers how to kill
and gut a sheep physically, so they can do it themselves when they go home;
there’s no problem with me just watching.
Ron
cuts the neck and makes an incision along the chest to a knob where our sternum
would be, but in a sheep (or lamb), this is called the brisket. It juts out and
has less wool on it—it’s right between the two front legs. He folds back the skin from this incision,
and briefly cleared some of the legs. At the brisket he punches the skin loose.
Then he
goes to the back legs and cuts the knee joint at the hock. These cuts are swift
and precise; the legs come off easily (the forefeet stay with the skin). The
cuts are made on the inside of the leg. He skins around the tail.
The
skin on the lamb is loose around the belly, so what Ron does is he pokes his
knife under the skin and through to the brisket so that he’s making a cut from
the inside. It’s easier to do it this way because the outside if covered in
wool, and also because if he were to slice from the outside he might
inadvertently slice the guts open and then smelly green goo would get
everywhere.
He cuts
the front feet off, and then he ties the throat with the wind pipe so that when
he hangs the sheep upside down the contents of the stomach don’t come up and
make a mess.
He
attaches a device called a gambril, which looks a little bit like a metal “}”,
to the ceiling, pokes a hole in each back leg between the bone and the hamstring,
and hangs the sheep up by these holes. The sheep is now hanging, head down,
belly out. The skin is still attached to the back of the sheep, as is the head.
At this
point Ron pulls the belly skin back, cuts round the tail, and then, with a
great heave, pulls the back skin off in one great pull. It pulls off easily, in
a great sheet.
That’s
when Ron cuts the head off in a single blow. As he says, “if you know what you’re
doing, it’s dead simple.” He spreads the head and the skin on the floor, and
except for the presence of the head, which doesn’t bother me too much, it looks
very much like my sheep skin rug back at home, which I walk on every day
without thinking about it. In fact, my sheep skin rug back home is exactly what
I’m looking at right now, except a different sheep (and probably mine is
slightly larger). This is the skin and the wool, and that is the skin and the
wool too. Mine has always had a slightly comforting but antiseptic feel about
it, but this doesn’t feel antiseptic at all.
Ron is
continuing, as I’m staring down at the sheep skin. He’s cut around the anus,
loosening the piping there. Then he’s cut right through the membrane so that
the guts do not get cut and spill out green goop everywhere. The way he does
this is he brings his fingers alongside the tip of his knife, with the handle
running on the inside of his palm, and gently slides the knife along the
membrane of the belly so that he can feel and cushion the guts and the knife
from one another as he cuts down. Once this cut is made, the stomach and intestines
will flop out whole. He reaches down
and cuts the diaphragm, grabs the trachea and esophagus, gives a jerk to free
them, and then the guts are free and spill out from the body, totally
disconnected. This includes the heart, the lungs, the kidneys,
liver—everything.
He puts
these on top of the rug that I am staring at, so that he can wrap everything up
and put it in the offal pit.
When I
look back at the skinned lamb, I’m stunned by how skinny it is. The stomach and
intestines and wool took up most of the space. When I looked at the lamb,
jiggling on the back of the bike with me, it looked so large but now it is a
spindly thing; now it is just muscle and bone.
Ron
says, “Ah, well, that’s done.”
Ron
says he’ll leave it hanging here for a day or so, depending on the weather. In
cold temperatures he would leave it for three or four days; in hot weather
maybe only a night. He leaves it there to mature and tenderize the meat. I ask
about flies and bacteria, and he tells me that any eggs that are laid they can
see, so he’ll just cut that part out, or flick them off, or wash them off, and
any bacteria will be washed off or cooked out; and that in fact when a meat is
just about to go bad it is at it’s most tender, and in those fancy restaurants
the state of the meat in the kitchen is sometimes a state you might not really be
too happy with knowing about. They won’t sell this lamb; they can’t sell it; so
it doesn’t matter, anyway.
Gay and
Simon have come in at some point. They are in high spirits, laughing and
joking. I’m in high spirits too, but I don’t add anything to the conversation
because I’m also trying to mentally record as much as possible.
Ron
tells the story of how he hit the lamb again, and I realize, later that night
when he tells it the third time, that telling the story, skinning and gutting
the lamb, taking the time to do it when he had other things to do, were in
service of helping himself recover from the shock of hitting a small animal,
his own animal, a baby animal that was just trying to follow its fellows in a
scary situation and didn’t know any better.
This is how he’s dealing with a small incident—telling this story and
skinning this lamb so that at least it’s contributing a little bit, so at least
it isn’t a total loss. But what, they’re going to get four or five dinners out
of this lamb, but they’re losing the cost of fixing the bike, as well as the
cost of selling the lamb. It IS a loss. A large one.
Simon
starts talking about his biology teacher and their recent dissection of pigs in
class. Gay pokes around in the offal and points out the heart, the lungs, the
kidneys, the small intestine versus the large. She notes that the lungs have
lines of red and purple down them where they were bruised against the ribs in
the accident. The bruising on the carcass is minimal, just a little along the
left leg, where we can see blood dribbling down. The flies might get to that
bit, but if so they’ll just cut that part away. Really, the lamb was killed by
the trauma to the lungs and head.
She
points back at the carcass and she notes that the muscles are still spasming.
Light flickers along one hip, one thigh, even without a head, without a heart,
without feet, still there are these small movements, remnants of life.
It
makes me feel better because when I was looking at another ewe that had died I
swore I could see it breathing, it looked so lifelike and I thought—don’t, no,
wait, it’s still there. But at that time, again, it was just the muscles still
spasming. Again, it was still the extra electrical impulses shocking it, and
something in my brain recognized movement. I couldn’t see it, but I knew it.
A
similar thing (though different) happened when I went to see David, in
Florence, Italy. David is, of course, much too big to be a real human. Also, he
happens to be made out of stone. But the proportions are such that something in
my brain recognized—human—and I
found myself trying to match my breathing to his, or trying to jump start his
breathing with my own, or at the very least tracking his lack of inhale and
waiting, always waiting for him to take that next breath, which I’m positive
that he will. Sometime, he will. Where is that next inhale; why isn’t he
inhaling; is he ok, is he ok, why isn’t he breathing?
I
actually couldn’t stay in the building for very long because I was getting
light headed.
I worry
about myself sometimes because I felt more for David than I do for a dead
sheep, or for a live sheep. Maybe that is a construction though—Michelangelo
wanted me to feel something more, so I do feel something more, whereas a sheep
does not need my emotions, and so I am not stirred at all.
How come
there are some animals that we feel so much for that when we die we feel
physically hurt by their passing? When Sherman, my cat, died I could physically
feel his death; the grief wasn’t just
emotional or mental, it was physical too. Like an orange fish of hurt swimming
through my blood stream. And you can say that that is love, and yes, ok, you
are right. But that is an easy answer. Why have I chosen to love this cat? This
small furry animal that is really just the same as any other furry animal? In
the Marshall Islands, way out in the Pacific Ocean, the islanders are afraid of
cats the way we are afraid of spiders or mice. What am I asking for when I take
care of a cat? I do not shear it or collect its eggs or babies or meat. I
collect its love. Does the cat give me its love as forfeit, because it knows I
require it, as payment for food and protection? Would it give me its love if I
didn’t provide food or protection? Does
it have any love to give, or am I just interpreting its movements as love
because I don’t know any better?
When
you love someone and they die—I have no experience in this—you know,
theoretically, where you stand. You know what relationship you had with that
person. You know, theoretically, what that person wanted. But with animals,
with the death of animals, you do not know. Some animals get thrown into the
offal pit. Some animals get skinned and eaten. Some animals get taken to the
pet cemetery and their graves are tended to with wreaths every Sunday. It seems
almost arbitrary, and that arbitrariness seems almost cruel. This animal should
be loved, but this one should be eaten, and this one should be neglected and
hated.
Just
like when the weaned lambs rushed past Simon, there is no way to stop it now.
There is no way to stop the killing of animals, the arbitrary love or hate of
animals by humans. You cannot now go back and study each animal, asking, “What would
you like? Would you like to be eaten? Offal pit more your style? Or would you
like to be stuffed into pink sweaters and made to be posed for calendars with
various jazz instruments?”
You
cannot now say, “Humans, stop making determinations. Stop being so
individualistic. Stop playing God.” Or, you can say that but how many would
hear you? The rush is too heavy past you in one direction, and there are no
motor bikes to get everyone rushing in the other direction. The cultures and
religions that celebrate the removal of the self are becoming archaic, are becoming less a
true way of life and instead are becoming relegated to snippets of reading or
an hour long class two days a week; they are a way of pretending so that some people can feel better about
themselves in comparison to the poor shmuck next to them. And yes, some
individuals genuinely operate this way, but they are not mobs of people. I have
no experience with this, but even the cultures that practice these less
individualistic ways are also adopting western methods and practices, are
changing and shifting and molding to a more global culture, and soon things
will not be as they were before. This is not necessarily a bad thing; it just is.
No one
on the farm wants a lamb or a ewe to die because it means seventy dollars down.
If the ewe snaps her leg it means a terrifying thirty seconds while she
struggles to free herself and then Ron has to slit her throat. It is panic and
it is fear. It is smell and flies and an offal pit.
But
that is routine on the farm, and so feeling nothing is helpful, is expected. The
lambs are cute but also stupid and fearful. They are not malleable or willing
to be helped, so when they bash their brain pan in—it happens. You leave them
where they lie and come back for them later.
There are ewes, “pets,” that were raised on the bottle
because they were orphans. Some of them have personalities and names and get
remembered, year after year, and live through year after year. Pets don’t get
sent to The Works if they can help it. They’re less skittish around humans.
I recently
met a pet, Heidi, who weighed in at 288 pounds when we took her through the run
to dag her. She’s currently fourteen years old and her feet have been buckling
in because she can’t support her own weight. She’ll live on the farm until she
dies in her sleep, or of natural causes. There are sheep that Gay and Ron
track, like Heidi, throughout the years, and fondly keep a hold of because they
produce lambs every year and keep themselves out of trouble and have a long
life on the farm. They’re few and far between, but they are there.
We
sheared Heidi, and then herded her and one other (slowly, because Heidi was not
particularly afraid of us nor inclined to walk too fast) up out of the mud
paddock behind the covered yard into another paddock, where they could put her
on half feed so they could trim her up a bit, so she could lose some weight and
hopefully walk a little better. As we were coming back, Ron stopped me. I didn’t
have my camera with me, for which I apologize sincerely.
He
stopped me and motioned me to be quiet, and then parted some grasses.
There
was a mother peahen, and right behind her was three—no, four—no, five, oh wait,
a sixth one just scuttle around that plant—little baby peachicks. The peahen
had been sitting on her eggs and they’d just hatched, and Ron must have seen a
movement in the grass. They were small, brown, duckling like things, but they
were probably only a couple days old, if that. Ron says that it’ll take them
several months to grow to any size at all. Ducks grow very fast, but peafowl
take a much longer time. She may also only end up rearing one or two, because
if she takes them in the shorter, wet grass, the peachicks will get cold and
wet and will die a lot easier. So if she keeps them safe and off the wet grass,
they’re more likely to all live.
But
with thirteen peacocks strutting around already, they really don’t need six
more.
Still.
It was really lovely to see six little peachicks waddling along.
Next up: the Shearing Post, the Catlins, my flora of NZ post, and the birds of the farm post! (aka, that's enough death and dismemberment for now. Thanks for reading.)
Dear Corrie,
ReplyDeleteI dutifully read this post even though I scrolled down first to look at the pictures and did not at all want to read about the innards and the sheep hanging in the shed, etc. But, even though I'm vegetarian, I think it's good for me to read posts like this, because in the end I'm vegetarian because I care about good food and the environment. I know not everyone is going to become a vegetarian; people are always going to eat meat, so I want to support people who raise meat in the best way possible. To that end it's good to know about the whole process.
I didn't respond to this post for a long time because I was thinking about animals, and David, and taking love from an animal in exchange for food, and asking an animal would you prefer to be meat or stuffed in a pink sweater and photographed or left out in the wild but maybe shot or eaten alive. You're right that even with pets humans take something from the animals, we keep pets around for our own purposes, largely because we want to feel unconditional love. I wish it wasn't that way, and maybe it won't always be, but you're right that there most likely will not be an overnight revolution in thought about the rights of animals to determine their own lifestyle. At least with pets it's better to have them in our homes than for them to be in a cage at the SPCA. :(
It's interesting to think about why cultures like certain animals and not others...in a way the animals we keep around show what we are lacking. Like in Tunisia there are wild cats all over the place. One reason the Tunisians generally like cats is because they keep the disease carrying rat population down. So in Tunis they are lacking the regular trash collection systems that would otherwise keep the rats away, and that leads to liking cats. Wild dogs, on the other hand, they tend to have no fondness for and don't tolerate them hanging around because they don't kill rats and don't serve any other purpose. I wonder if the Tunisians didn't develop a relationship with dogs as much as other cultures because their houses generally have walls all the way around them, so they wouldn't really need guard dogs as much. Out in the country in Tunisia people have dogs for herding sheep and goats though. I think in America we keep cats and dogs because we are kind of stand-offish and we don't get as much love as we need. Maybe that's why so many cultures have pets. We all need more love.
On the other hand I think we have to create an emotional wall between us and something that we don't like but that is inevitable, like killing sheep that you've put a lot of energy, and really love, into raising. Even if you're only around the sheep for a month, I think you'd still have to create that distance or else you'd just get too overwhelmed to go on. We do that for all kinds of things though, just so that we can keep going. So in some ways I think it's normal to feel more for David than for sheep, especially because you know ahead of time the sheep are going to be slaughtered, so you know ahead of time to put your block up so that you don't freak out.
There are some animals that we like and don't mess with though, like raccoons. When I see the raccoons wandering around Ames I don't get anything from them other than a cuteness endorphin rush, but I love having them around. Maybe those kinds of animals are the ones we would have liked to have as pets like cats and dogs, but who said, "I don't want to live in a house!! It isn't an even trade to let you pet me in exchange for food from a can! Screw you!" and went on their merry way. So maybe cats and dogs did make a choice to live with us...they could have just walked off like a raccoon...maybe.
I think humans do the best we can, in a lot of places--like what you talk about in tunisia, like what you talk about with our culture and pets and needing love, etc. I think that some people abuse animals but other people try to prevent that abuse, too. I think that balance has always been there--we've always had to tread that line. How much can we take from other living creatures before it's unethical? How much can we give them in return without knowing what they actually want and need? I don't think these questions are new. I think we've been thinking about these since we started cultivating animals, since we started domesticating them. They may not have been popular questions, and sometimes humans decided that the answers that went in their favor were the right answers.
ReplyDeleteBut yeah, I think cats decided to stick around of their own volition. Dogs I think were domesticated intentionally, but cats have had very few intential changes made to them (except for breeds)--unlike dogs, where we can see a dramatic shift from wolves to domesticated dogs. Cats seem to just decide, "hey, this is a good deal."
So. There you go.
And I'm glad you read the post. I hope you didn't feel too upset--the sheep on the farm are treated very well, and as kindly as possible. When they're taken to "the Works" they're just shot once in the head, so that they don't know anything about what's happening, the most humane way. And before that--megan, you would love the farm. There's so much room for them to romp in, and lovely manuka for them to wend and hide in, and hills and trees, and sometimes the goats come and visit them. It's great. So these sheep, at least, have a really good life. I don't think all farms are this well cared for, this well planned, and this well managed, so that's something to take into consideration.
Corrie